OK, I'm going to settle all of this Heisman nonsense once and for all. Here's the most definitive Heisman analysis you'll find anywhere!
For this Heisman race, you can boil it all down to two basic things, yards and touchdowns. The object of the game is to move the ball down the field and, most importantly, score, right? So, take a look at the four finalists and check out how they did in terms of helping their teams move the ball and score touchdowns.
Check out these stats...
| Candidate | Total Yards | Touchdowns |
| Brennan * | 4239 yds | 46 TDs |
| Daniel ** | 4454 yds | 37 TDs |
| McFadden | 1889 yds | 16 TDs |
| Tebow | 3970 yds | 51 TDs |
* - Colt Brennan only played in 10 full games.
** - Chase Daniel played in 13 games.
Let's talk about each candidate.
Brennan - Colt Brennan, though he only played in 10 games, played against really poor competition. The teams he played against were a combined 42-80 with only 2 teams (Boise State and Fresno State) having a winning record. For of these teams had either 1 or 2 wins.
Daniel - Chase Daniel played 6 games against teams that had winning records and won 4 of them. His only really poor game was the Big 12 Championship against Oklahoma. He played well against them the first time they met, but not the second time.
McFadden - Darren McFadden, while he did have over 1700 yards rushing, virtually disappeared in 3 games. He had 64 carries for 192 yards (3.3 yds/car) against MSU, FIU and Auburn combined. He only played against 7 teams with winning records.
Tebow - Tim Tebow rushed for almost 900 yards and had more rushing touchdowns (22) than McFadden (15). He passed for 29 touchdowns and is the first player to run and pass for 20 TDs in NCAA FBS history. 10 of the 12 teams that Tebow played against had winning records. For the most part, he played well in their 3 losses. His "worst" performance was against #1 LSU, and still almost led Florida to a win.
Combining all of these factors,
Tim Tebow is clearly the correct pick for the Heisman Trophy. He performed at the highest level against superior competition and his 51 TDs are tops in the group.